GNC Pro Performance® AMP Amplified 100% Whey Protein-Vanilla | Melaleuca ProFlex20™ Shake – Classic Vanilla | GNC Pro Performance® AMP Amplified 100% Whey Protein-Vanilla | |
PRICE | ~ $40 (Amazon) | $16.99 (Melaleuca) | ~ $40 (Amazon) |
PRICE per gram* | $0.030/gram | $0.037/gram | $0.030/gram |
Serving Size | 3 scoops (79g) | 2 scoops (31g) | 2 scoops (52.67g) |
Servings per container | 17 | 15 | 25.5 |
Calories | 280 | 150 | 186.67 |
Calories from Fat | 10 | 40 | 6.67 |
Total Fat | 1g | 4.5g | <1g |
Sat. Fat | 0.5g | 1g | <0.5g |
Trans Fat | n/a | 0g | n/a |
Cholesterol | 20mg | 10mg | 13.33mg |
Total Carbs | 7g | 11g | 4.67g |
Dietary Fiber | 1g | 5g | <1g |
Sugars | 2g | 2g | 1.33g |
Protein | 60g | 20g | 40g |
Sodium | 350mg | 75mg | 233.33mg |
* More accurate price breakdown since the serving sizes are not exactly the same. |
The first row is from the Wheybolic label, while the 3rd row shows how I use the Wheybolic protein - 2 scoops instead of 3. At first glance, it appears that the Wheybolic is the better choice - more protein, less fat per serving, etc. However, the sodium is significantly higher. I also know that Melaleuca uses better ingredients that are closer to nature. I also have to think about how much protein do I really need. It is better to get your protein from natural sources - meats, beans, etc. But, if I need to utilize a different source (like a protein powder), how much do I really need? To answer this question, I had to do a little more research. After reviewing several medical and bodybuilding websites, I came to the conclusion that anything under 30g at one sitting is absorbed at the highest efficiency. Anything over, and you're going to be looking at some waste. You also need to take into account how much protein you have had over the day, or plan to have. In general, you should ingest 1g of protein for every pound you weigh. If you are eating a high protein diet, then you may not need a protein powder with a higher protein count. Basically, it depends on the individual and their needs.
CONCLUSION:
In general, I personally need a powder with more protein because I am not good at making sure I get enough every day. But, before I could even get that far, I wrote off the ProFlex based on taste alone. Using the ProFlex protein would save me a little money, and I feel like the ingredients are of a higher quality, but I just don't like the taste. For this race, the Wheybolic wins. Sorry, Melaleuca - ya just can't win 'em all!
i know its an old review and i love the taste and all my customers,, its a good protein, i know people who have bought proteins and broke out in spots this is very good product
ReplyDeletePat
Try the dutch chocalate... no need to add anything to it and taste great with just water! :)
ReplyDelete